Lake Mills, WI home values & market trends
A market snapshot for the Lake Mills area in Jefferson County, covering ZIP 53551. Prices are a 12-month median of asking prices, not closed sales, so one unusual month does not set the headline. For what your specific home is worth, get matched with a local agent below.
Typical list price
$494,938
12-month median · listed now $496,175
Year over year
+10.0%
Trailing 12 months vs the 12 before
Days on market
35
Median for current listings
Price / sq ft
$221
12-month median, per sq ft
Active listings
23
Homes currently for sale
These figures come from 23 active listings in ZIP 53551, a modest sample, so read them as a general direction rather than a precise value.
Over these 60 months the Lake Mills median ranged from $374,200 to $525,000, finishing at $496,175. Asking prices, not closed sales.
5 of the 60 months shown had fewer than 12 homes listed, where the median moves on a single listing.
Covers ZIP 53551 · Listing data via Realtor.com · Updated June 2026
About the Lake Mills market
Built around Rock Lake and a town square, Lake Mills sits between Madison and Milwaukee.
Free home valuation
What's your Lake Mills home actually worth?
Market averages are a starting point, but your home's real value depends on its condition, updates, and exact location. Get matched with a vetted Lake Mills-area agent for a free, no-obligation valuation of your specific home.
- A real local agent, not an algorithm
- Free & no obligation
- Based on your home's actual details
Market statistics shown are aggregate listing figures for the ZIP codes noted above, combined across ZIPs and weighted by the number of active listings in each. ZIP code areas are set by the postal service and do not match city limits exactly, so the coverage is an approximation of the Lake Mills market rather than an exact match for it. These figures are for general informational purposes and are not an appraisal or valuation of any specific property. They reflect homes currently or recently listed, not closed sales, and vary by condition, location, and features. For a valuation of your home, consult a licensed real estate professional.